Fifth Avenue Forensics

Psychiatric Defense Evaluations

Complete Case Review
& Consultation

Connect with a Fifth Avenue Forensics expert to discuss your case and learn more about our comprehensive forensic evaluations and assessments.

Skyscrapers in New York

Understanding Psychiatric Defense in Legal Contexts

Assessing the impact of an individual’s mental illness at the time of the offense can have a profound impact on their degree of legal responsibility and culpability. These psychiatric defenses, which are better classified as “excuse” defenses rather than “justification” defenses, are primarily concerned with the defendant’s mental state during the time of the alleged offense. Comprehensive assessments conducted by a psychologist or a psychiatrist are necessary to evaluate the nature and legitimacy of such claims and assist the trier of fact in assessing the defendant’s culpability.

Our Approach to Psychiatric Defense Evaluations

The primary goal of a psychiatric defense evaluation is to provide an unbiased, comprehensive assessment of the defendant’s mental state at the time of the alleged offense. Our evaluations aim to illuminate if and how a defendant’s mental illness may have influenced their understanding and choices, ultimately impacting their legal culpability. In addition, we work to distinguish those individuals who are genuinely afflicted with a psychiatric illness from individuals who may be exaggerating or malingering to obtain a favorable outcome. The results of these evaluations have significant implications on the course and outcome of legal proceedings.

Criminal responsibility evaluations encompass various legal defenses that pertain to the mental state of the accused individual at the time of the offense. These include not guilty by reason of insanity, extreme emotional disturbance, and negated intent.

Key components of our evaluations include:

  • Comprehensive Mental State Assessment: We conduct an exhaustive examination of the defendant’s mental state at the time of the alleged offense. This includes evaluating their understanding of the nature of their actions and the potential consequences.
  • In-depth Psychiatric Evaluation: Our team conducts a detailed psychiatric assessment, including the review of collateral information, to determine the presence of any mental illnesses or psychological conditions. This can help establish whether the defendant had the mental capacity to comprehend and control their actions at the time of the offense.
  • Evaluation of Legal Constructs: We review legal constructs that may impact culpability, such as insanity defense or diminished capacity. This involves a nuanced understanding of the law and its intersection with psychiatric factors. Our evaluations inform the court about the defendant’s mental state and potential eligibility for certain defenses.

Your Reliable Partner for Psychiatric Defense Evaluations

Fifth Avenue Forensics is your trusted partner for professional psychiatric defense evaluations. Our objective and meticulous evaluations, backed by the unrivaled experience of professionals like Dr. Bardey, can provide crucial insights into cases involving defendants with mental illnesses. Trust us to deliver accurate, comprehensive, and impactful psychiatric evaluations that can help ensure fair and informed legal proceedings.