Bailey McCarthy, LMHC

Meet Bailey McCarthy, a New York State Licensed Mental Health Counselor specializing in forensic mental health, trauma-informed care, and community-based treatment. With experience across clinical, legal, and advocacy settings, Bailey brings a compassionate, systems-focused approach to her work at Fifth Avenue Forensics.

Bailey McCarthy, LMHC

Licensed Mental Health Counselor

New York State Licensed Mental Health Counselor

Bailey McCarthy is a licensed mental health counselor in New York State with specialized expertise at the intersection of psychology, criminal justice, and community mental health. Her experience includes forensic evaluation, intensive community-based treatment, and systems-level advocacy. Bailey’s commitment to trauma-informed care and client empowerment makes her a vital member of the team at Fifth Avenue Forensics.

Grounded in Psychology and Forensic Mental Health

Ms. McCarthy holds a Bachelor of Science in Psychology from the College of William & Mary and a Master’s degree in Forensic Mental Health Counseling from John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Her academic training provided a strong foundation in psychological theory and the complex intersections between mental health and the legal system.

In-Depth Field Experience Across Systems

Ms. McCarthy began her field experience as a researcher through Columbia University, contributing to a longitudinal 9/11 study focused on trauma and long-term mental health outcomes. She later worked as a restorative justice facilitator in Virginia, supporting justice-involved youth through structured dialogue and community-based alternatives to incarceration. During graduate school, she interned at Fifth Avenue Forensics, assisting in evaluations for mental health court diversion and victim advocacy.

Serving High-Risk Populations with Compassion and Commitment

Before rejoining Fifth Avenue Forensics, Ms. McCarthy was a therapist and substance use specialist on an Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) team in the Bronx. She provided intensive, community-based care to young adults with severe mental illness, supporting access to housing, social services, and community programming. Her work integrated therapy, psychoeducation, family support, and harm reduction, with a focus on empowering clients to make informed decisions and engage fully in their treatment.

A Commitment to Advocacy and Systemic Change

In her current role as a Forensic Mitigation Specialist and Psychotherapist, Ms. McCarthy supports individuals facing criminal charges through clinical treatment and legal advocacy.
She integrates psychological insight into mitigation strategies to promote more equitable, trauma-informed outcomes. Her dedication to autonomy, dignity, and treatment over punishment informs every aspect of her work with clients and interdisciplinary teams.